General Discussion Confessing Our Sins to One Another?

William D'Andrea

Well-known member
Joined
Mar 6, 2017
Messages
3,382
Reaction score
1,711
I have an idea that I think might be helpful to discuss.
James 5: 14-16 states:
"Is anyone among you sick? Let him call for the elders of the church, and let them pray over him, anointing him with oil in the name of the Lord. And the prayer of faith will save the one who is sick, and the Lord will raise him up. And if he has committed sins, he will be forgiven. Therefore, confess your sins to one another and pray for one another, that you may be healed. The prayer of a righteous person has great power as it is working."
Should we members of christianwriters.com confess our sins to one another? Over the internet?
 
Should we members of christianwriters.com confess our sins to one another? Over the internet?
I don't recommend this, @William D'Andrea. Our site is viewable to the public and the confessions wouldn't be confidential.

I also ask you to remember the focus of this site is writing. Yes, we all share fellowship and faith in Christ through our writing and posts. However most of what you're asking is better addressed through your local church family. :)
 
I don't recommend this, @William D'Andrea. Our site is viewable to the public and the confessions wouldn't be confidential.

I also ask you to remember the focus of this site is writing. Yes, we all share fellowship and faith in Christ through our writing and posts. However most of what you're asking is better addressed through your local church family. :)
Thank you Rebecca. You are correct. I was just wondering. If we don't confess our sins, we can still get very helpful advice from one another, while minding our own business.
 
Thank you, William. From many of your posts, it seems you're seeking much more than we can offer as a writing site. As I mentioned above, your local church family is best suited to guide you spiritually.

In case you would prefer online resources, I've also placed two links below. These will bring up a search of free online Christian sites that are more equipped to handle the type of in-depth fellowship and prayer requests you are seeking. I haven't screened these sites, so please use your discernment.

I hope this helps you find what you are looking for. :)

Prayer request sites:

Christian Fellowship sites:
 
I hope this helps you find what you are looking for. :)
Thank you Rebecca. I've just joined the effectivedailyprayer.com website and posted three prayer requests. In Jesus Name. Amen.
This does not mean that I'm leaving christianwriters.com. I consider all of you my online friends, who I'd never want to give up. I intend to keep on posting here.
 
Last edited:
William, over the years, I have been blessed to have found godly women who are trustworthy. The ministries that I have served in yielded me
some sisters very strong in their faith. They are, also, part of my accountability team. Our enemy is relentless. So, it's good to have believers you can trust to "shoulder you up" while you are running this race. If you don't have such connections, William, let me encourage you to ask the Lord to lead you to, at least, two.
Mine live in different states. But, they're never more than a phone call away. They can, also, count on me for the same availability and discretion.
William, King Jesus is faithful and generous. He knows what we need even before we ask. Ask and you will receive. Or, maybe, the recommendations from Rebecca has already fulfilled your need.
🙏🏾
 
Last edited:
Men's issues are often a bit different than women's issues, and coed is usually not a good safe space to air issues of lust, pornography, anger, past abandonment of families, addictions, etc.

Though the genders share more of these than you might imagine, it's often common to get more condemnation than confrontation and encouragement when you cross the streams. I used to belong to a place called MensForum that did this rather anonymously. You created an account with whatever handle you wanted and then could discuss any issues you were having, request prayer, and find some level of support.

That forum is now defunct, but there are others. The biggest issue with sharing needs and prayer requests of that nature, airing your dirty laundry, is gossip and character assassination, which is not a stranger, unfortunately, to Christian circles.

Hi, I'm pastor Jack Jimmybob Johnson from Jonesboro and I've been cheating on my wife. Can you pray for me to cut off relations with my mistress, reconcile with my wife, and repair damage with my kids?
Hi, I'm deacon Dwight Doubtright from the church down the street from yours, and I've made sure you're an EX pastor, EX husband, and EX member of your EX church.

I expect that a lot of us here on this forum don't deal with sin on that level, but no doubt some of us do. If you are looking for accountability, you're going to need a close friend you can trust IRL. You might have grown one or two of those over the years. Just joining a men's group at your local church is a recipe for disaster. For example, when I was having struggles, I joined one at my church. 20 men in the room at one guy's house. Supposedly all dealing with men's issues. I was desperate for some help and answers. But when we met, nobody would speak. It was like a one hour silent treatment. Nobody wanted to open up. So I did, finally. I think it shocked a lot of the guys there, they thought I was perfect. (I put on a really good front). Even after I did, everyone else was completely afraid to open up. I discovered later that some of them told their wives, who eventually told others, until I got stares at church. My wife knew about my struggles, so when word got back to her, she quietly suggested I find a different and smaller group. I'm sharing just a tad here only because it's now public knowledge - I've put some of these stories in the books I've written.

LOL - But I wonder if it got further when it was just gossip.

A men's forum can be a good place to air issues without risk, a safe space to get advice and prayer. but not really for accountability. Accountability on an anonymous forum is as powerful as a rubberband gun. After all, you can always just kill your account or forward all your notifications to the bit bucket.
 
I know that in the Catholic Church, they have booths called confessionals, where the Priest hears confessions, from people who are hidden from him. He never repeats what he's heard.
In Protestant Churches it's not that way. I don't think I've ever heard anything specific.
As for myself, I just confess to the Lord, Who already knows what I've done. Then He helps me put the sins behind me and leads me in righteousness. In Jesus Name. Amen.
 
So, maybe I'm unsure what your purpose was in your initial post. Were you asking if there is a biblical mandate to confess to each other rather than just to God? Or were you seeking such a place and thought here would be that place?
 
So, maybe I'm unsure what your purpose was in your initial post. Were you asking if there is a biblical mandate to confess to each other rather than just to God? Or were you seeking such a place and thought here would be that place?
I was just wondering about what the Bible says about confessing to each other. I was also looking to start a good discussion, and it looks like that's what's happening.
 
Men's issues are often a bit different than women's issues, and coed is usually not a good safe space to air issues of lust, pornography, anger, past abandonment of families, addictions, etc.

Though the genders share more of these than you might imagine, it's often common to get more condemnation than confrontation and encouragement when you cross the streams. I used to belong to a place called MensForum that did this rather anonymously. You created an account with whatever handle you wanted and then could discuss any issues you were having, request prayer, and find some level of support.

That forum is now defunct, but there are others. The biggest issue with sharing needs and prayer requests of that nature, airing your dirty laundry, is gossip and character assassination, which is not a stranger, unfortunately, to Christian circles.

Hi, I'm pastor Jack Jimmybob Johnson from Jonesboro and I've been cheating on my wife. Can you pray for me to cut off relations with my mistress, reconcile with my wife, and repair damage with my kids?
Hi, I'm deacon Dwight Doubtright from the church down the street from yours, and I've made sure you're an EX pastor, EX husband, and EX member of your EX church.

I expect that a lot of us here on this forum don't deal with sin on that level, but no doubt some of us do. If you are looking for accountability, you're going to need a close friend you can trust IRL. You might have grown one or two of those over the years. Just joining a men's group at your local church is a recipe for disaster. For example, when I was having struggles, I joined one at my church. 20 men in the room at one guy's house. Supposedly all dealing with men's issues. I was desperate for some help and answers. But when we met, nobody would speak. It was like a one hour silent treatment. Nobody wanted to open up. So I did, finally. I think it shocked a lot of the guys there, they thought I was perfect. (I put on a really good front). Even after I did, everyone else was completely afraid to open up. I discovered later that some of them told their wives, who eventually told others, until I got stares at church. My wife knew about my struggles, so when word got back to her, she quietly suggested I find a different and smaller group. I'm sharing just a tad here only because it's now public knowledge - I've put some of these stories in the books I've written.

LOL - But I wonder if it got further when it was just gossip.

A men's forum can be a good place to air issues without risk, a safe space to get advice and prayer. but not really for accountability. Accountability on an anonymous forum is as powerful as a rubberband gun. After all, you can always just kill your account or forward all your notifications to the bit bucket.
Oh my. I had never considered the entire ramifications of public confession. I suppose one should be ready for everything to be public. In the end it will be. In a way its a shame that we cannot keep confidential our discussions among Christians. I, for one, consider myself the lowest of the low.
 
Oh my. I had never considered the entire ramifications of public confession. I suppose one should be ready for everything to be public. In the end it will be. In a way its a shame that we cannot keep confidential our discussions among Christians. I, for one, consider myself the lowest of the low.
Yep, that chilling, "What's done in secret will be shouted from the rooftops. I'm not sure if that includes all our dirty laundry as Christians, or whether what is under the blood is therefore no longer open for discussion, a private matter between you and your maker, that He has forgiven and buried in the depths of the sea. There are plenty of places in scripture where God tells us he has removed them as far as the east from the west, that though we were crimson, we can be white as wool.

Reconciling that against the rooftop shouting seems difficult, and may be a difference between the sheep and the goats. Those who persecuted and abused, who cheated and slandered, who backstabbed and secretly plotted, who are not TRULY in the faith, when the last day comes, those secrets will all be made known. There will be nothing hidden that will not come to light.

For me, I'll be glad to be there, and in the faith, even if the wreckage I've created in my wake comes to full light. In the light of eternity in heaven I don't think that momentary pain will be any considerable price to pay, even if everyone has to know about it. I don't think we will be pokiing at one another anyway, as every human that has walked the earth would have the same issue. Though for some it will not be anger, or lust, but gossip, or greed. And if none of those apply, if you've done exceptionally well and your own righteousness rivals Job, you'll probably be dealing with Pride.

The ticket price to heaven was paid by Christ, and our righteousness on our own is just nasty rags. So it's not going to be by works. it will be by faith. But if we are His, there will be a part of us that wants to act like it, and as we grow, that part should get bigger, and the selfish part should decrease as you die to it daily.
 
Yep, that chilling, "What's done in secret will be shouted from the rooftops. I'm not sure if that includes all our dirty laundry as Christians, or whether what is under the blood is therefore no longer open for discussion, a private matter between you and your maker, that He has forgiven and buried in the depths of the sea. There are plenty of places in scripture where God tells us he has removed them as far as the east from the west, that though we were crimson, we can be white as wool.

Reconciling that against the rooftop shouting seems difficult, and may be a difference between the sheep and the goats. Those who persecuted and abused, who cheated and slandered, who backstabbed and secretly plotted, who are not TRULY in the faith, when the last day comes, those secrets will all be made known. There will be nothing hidden that will not come to light.

For me, I'll be glad to be there, and in the faith, even if the wreckage I've created in my wake comes to full light. In the light of eternity in heaven I don't think that momentary pain will be any considerable price to pay, even if everyone has to know about it. I don't think we will be pokiing at one another anyway, as every human that has walked the earth would have the same issue. Though for some it will not be anger, or lust, but gossip, or greed. And if none of those apply, if you've done exceptionally well and your own righteousness rivals Job, you'll probably be dealing with Pride.

The ticket price to heaven was paid by Christ, and our righteousness on our own is just nasty rags. So it's not going to be by works. it will be by faith. But if we are His, there will be a part of us that wants to act like it, and as we grow, that part should get bigger, and the selfish part should decrease as you die to it daily.
You reminded me of a story.....don't know the author or if the story is true.

An old country doctor had semi retired and moved his office into his old farm house.

He was sitting in his office with an elderly gentleman and had just given him the test results. They were not good.

The elderly gentleman was shaken and in a low voice asked the doctor, "Doc I'm afraid to die. Isn" there anything that can be done?"

At the shake of the doctors head the man began to sob.

There was a scratching sound on the door and the doctor got up and opened the door. A large old german shepard bounded in and licked his hand. Then the dog settled in a corner never taking his eyes off his master.

The doctor looked at the old man and said, "You know I"m no preacher. But did you notice my dog? He has never been in this office but all he knew was that I was here. I believe the same way. II don"t know whats on the other side of that door into the after life. But I know my master is there and I want to be with Him."

End of little story.

I feel the same. I dont know what is going to happen...all I know is I want to be with Jesus.
 

Recent Discussions

Back
Top