It doesn't have to be hymns. I was hoping we would aim for songs we know and like so that maybe others (including myself) could maybe learn about new ones ... but it was primarily for fun, so whatever works.
OK, I admit I cheated. I went to cyberhymnal, which now seems to be hymntime.com.
Quiet Hour (with three different tunes)
Quiet Is the Hour of Even
Quiet, Lord, My Froward Heart
Quit You like Men (two different tunes)
I almost typed "Yesterday" as my youth leader had introduced this song to the group once. All this time I didn't know who wrote it so looked it up. The Beatles? It was however sung by many others. Does anyone know if a Christian artist adapted this? Would you consider it a Christian song?